When the design of the Ipod Nano was first announced in September of 2005, fans of Apple’s products were rejoicing. Enthusiasts could now enjoy all the same features of its larger brother, the Ipod, but now in a compact form. At the debut media showing, Steve Jobs pulled the Nano from his pocket to demonstrate how small it is. If you could imagine 5 credit cards stacked upon each other, then you could imagine the size and depth of the Nano. The buzz was there. Fans were frothing at the mouth. Apple was at the top of their game.
There was a problem though.
The front screens were breaking – and they broke easily. Nano owners attempted to imitate Steve and carry their Nano in the front pocket of their jeans. Once they pulled the Nano from their pockets they were shocked to see the screen cracked and scratched as if their pockets were lined with sandpaper. Fans were upset. Apple was mum on answering complaints. Those with broken screens wanted an answer. What would they do? Boycott the Nano? Take it up with large media outlets? Neither.
They utilized the power of the Web and got Apple to respond.
The Internet has allowed the mass collaboration of similar individuals. There are no borders on the Internet (that is if you don’t live in China). Geography, what used to be a barrier to collaboration, has become marginalized. As best selling author Tom Friedman says: the Internet has ‘flattened’ the world. If you have access to a computer and a high speed connection, you can participate on the Internet.
This low barrier to entry has spawned what is known as ‘social media’. You’ve experienced social media if you have ever visited a blog, or websites such as Flickr, MySpace, or YouTube.
Social media can be thought as the online tools (blogs, wiki’s, message boards) which allow people to create and share content which expresses their opinions and perspectives with others. Those who create this content are called ‘Citizen Marketers’. Ben McConnell and Jackie Huba, who are word-of-mouth marketing experts, examine the dynamics of this group of citizens in their new book, “Citizen Marketers: When People are the Message”.
“Citizen Marketers create what could be considered marketing and advertising content on behalf of people, brands, products, or organizations.”
Ben and Jackie have broken down Citizen Marketers into four categories: Filters, Fanatics, Facilitators and Firecrackers. Below you’ll find text taken from the book that summarizes each category.
Filters
- “Human wire services. They collect traditional media stories, bloggers rants and raves, podcasts, or fan creations about a specific company or brand and then package this information”
-
“Amateur brand journalism..”
Fanatics
- “True believers and evangelists…they love to analyze the daily or weekly progress of a brand, product, or organization or persona and prescribe some courses of action. They are, essentially, volunteer coaches.”
- Food/entertainment topics are popular with fanatics
- “Assume activist role”
- “They want to contribute and often do so, even if the company isn’t listening.”
- “The delivery mechanisms built into many social media tools accelerate knowledge sharing. When collective knowledge is created at a faster rate, decisions can be made comparably faster, potentially resulting in faster action.”
Facilitators
- “Community creators. Their primary citizen marketer tool is a Web-based bulletin board or community software. Facilitators are like the mayors of online towns, and some online communities exceed the population of small cities.”
Firecrackers
- “Firecrackers are the one-hit wonders of citizen marketers.”
- “They typically attract considerable attention because they have created a song, animation, video, or novelty that generates a lot of interest but tends to die out quickly as the creators go one with their other work.”
As you can see, each group fulfills a special niche. One commonality of four groups is that their work incorporates the following traits:
- Personal Expression – opinions are their own, designed to inform, entertain, or analyze in a way that builds a case – unlike what a professional journalist, pundit, or analyst would do.
- Amateur status – volunteers and don’t announce their arrival with noisy banging of pots and pans of an expensive marketing program. They are transparent about their motives and associations.
- Freely given – Their work is not meant to steal money, time, or attention away from the company of their affiliation. It’s meant to enhance or improve it. Their work is a contribution to the commons.
“The future of personal publishing and the business of culture are being driven by the inherent ease and desire for people to build knowledge together.”
It’s important to point out the size of users who fit under the ‘Citizen Marketer’ title. Only those who create content can be classified under one of the four F’s. Ben and Jackie’s research discovered that roughly 1% of people who visit a democratized website will create and interact with the content. When looking at the latest statistics of web users that equals to roughly 10 million people. That is like the entire population of New York City creating and interacting on the Web. Not a small size!
A common attribute of the Citizen Marketer is the democratization of content they create. Transparency will always beat out secrecy with this crowd. The same goes with democratization of content compared to content control. To be successful in wooing the Citizen Marketer you have to have an open, democratized website. What do the authors refer to when speaking about democratization?
“To democratize something is to make it more socially equitable or available to a broader array of interested people. It distributes power and responsibility to the masses. Companies reduce risk by distributing it more evenly. “
What to do now?
Keys to democratizing your business:
The main ingredient for success is the democratization of the website content. Here are some ways to do so:
Contests – One of the easiest ways to experiment with citizen created content is with a contest. A perfect example is the commercial campaign that Doritos ran for the Super Bowl. Their contest called “Crash the Superbowl” has allowed citizens to submit their own commercials which are to be voted on by a community of users. This contest holds both the ideas of openness (allowing anyone to upload their commercial) and democratizing (allowing anyone to vote – Doritos doesn’t choose the winner- you do.)
Co-Creation – The t-shirt company Threadless has been as popular in my examples as they are in my clothes dresser. They are highlighted in the book as catering to the Citizen Marketer. They have given the amateur individual the ability to co-create t-shirts. Anyone with a design program and a computer can become apart of the community. Threadless doesn’t choose the winning designs, the community of users do. With the help of customers Threadless creates stylish t-shirts. If your design is selected to be placed for sale you get hooked up with gift certificates and free t-shirts. Allowing citizens to co-create builds a loyal fan base.
Community – The goal of building a community is to establish a central location on the web where fans can gather to discuss and debate all things relating to a product, movie, service, restaurant, ect.
A perfect example is TivoCommunity.com which has 130 thousand registered members and 1.2 million unique visits per month. It is the #1 site for users wishing to find and discuss anything relating to Tivo. The unique thing about TivoCommunity.com is that it has no affiliation with the company Tivo. The site was created by a fan of the product. Users have since flocked to the site creating a knowledge base which rivals anything Tivo could create on their own. Users have taken the open culture of forums and built a valuable resource for the technological device.
Apple not responding initially to broken screen complaints caused a negative backlash from a citizen marketer. This is where the power of one can create tipping points for action.
An owner of a broken Nano screen created a website under the URL flawedmusicplayer.com and posted pictures of his broken Nano. Shortly after the site appeared, word spread and he was receiving up to 30 emails an hour from other users with similar problems.
The site became a pressure point on Apple. Many believe the site was what forced Apple to change positions and finally release a statement that they would replace the broken screens.
The availability of high speed internet forever changed the way we are connected. The Internet is a 365×24x7 world and the Citizen Marketer will continue to play a vital role within it.
Some more goodies: